Skip to content
The Spore PatchPublishing · Evidence · Conservation

The Fungal Evidence Atlas

Evidence Updates


Dated surveillance bulletins recording new human evidence, preclinical signals, citation-integrity findings and the manuscript decisions that follow.

How to read these updates

Surveillance does not silently alter an Atlas grade.

Each bulletin records what was found, what the evidence belongs to, its limits and any action required. A formal change to a published position is documented separately in the correction record.

Evidence surveillance ·

Medicinal Fungi Evidence Brief

Research published or newly indexed 2–9 October 2026


“The week adds a plausible microbial mechanism, not a treatment claim. If the manuscript already insists on intervention-specific evidence, its central argument is strengthened — its clinical conclusions are not changed.”

What changed

No new human intervention study and no qualifying systematic review were found. One peer-reviewed mouse/mechanistic paper is worth monitoring because it isolates a chemically defined Ganoderma applanatum beta-glucan fraction and tests microbiota dependence. It does not support a clinical claim for G. applanatum, Ganoderma generally, or commercial mushroom products.

Evidence surveillance

Human clinical evidence


Newly indexed human evidence is assessed against the exact formulation and study design, without transferring results to a mushroom species or product category.

Human clinical evidence

No eligible new human intervention study was identified in the surveillance window.

The human component of the G. applanatum paper below is a secondary analysis of existing ulcerative-colitis metagenomic cohorts (460 healthy controls and 575 patients). It measures associations in microbial abundance and biosynthetic genes, not clinical effects of a mushroom intervention.

Manuscript verdict

No change. Clinical evidence grades remain unchanged.

Source: Medicinal Fungi Evidence Brief, 9 October 2026

Systematic reviews / meta-analyses

No new systematic review or intervention meta-analysis met the inclusion criteria.

The cohort pooling embedded in the Advanced Science paper is not a systematic review and should not be described as treatment evidence. It is hypothesis-supporting observational analysis only.

Evidence rule used in this brief: conclusions belong to the exact intervention tested — species, material, fraction, processing and dose — not to ‘the mushroom’ as a category.

Manuscript verdict

No change. Do not add a pooled clinical estimate.

Source: Medicinal Fungi Evidence Brief, 9 October 2026

Laboratory and animal research

Preclinical signals


Signals that may justify monitoring or further investigation, but do not establish a human clinical effect.

Purified G. applanatum GAP2 in DSS colitis

Peer-reviewed original paper | Advanced Science | Published 6 October 2026.

Exact tested intervention. Dry fruiting bodies of Ganoderma applanatum from Changbai Mountain, China; identity confirmed by the Chinese Academy of Sciences and voucher CCFM20221205 retained. Material underwent hot-water extraction, ethanol precipitation, DEAE anion-exchange chromatography and Superdex 75 size-exclusion chromatography. The principal fraction, GAP2, was the 0.2 mol/L NaCl-eluted fraction: a roughly 20.5 kDa linear beta-(1→3)-glucan, concentrated and lyophilized.

Dose, model and comparators. In the main screen, male C57BL/6j mice received 3% DSS plus crude polysaccharides (300 mg/kg by gavage) or GAP1–GAP4 (50 mg/kg by gavage); model controls received PBS or saline. Randomized groups began at n=10, with reported endpoint subsets commonly n=5–7. Further randomized experiments used germ-free mice, fecal microbiota transfer, filtered fecal metabolites, Phocaeicola vulgatus FTJS7K1, and GH16/fabB knockout strains.

Outcomes. GAP2 improved weight recovery, colon length, histology, mucin and tight-junction markers in DSS-treated mice. In germ-free mice, direct GAP1/GAP2 dosing was largely null; transfer of microbiota or filtered metabolites from treated donors restored effects. The authors link GAP2 fermentation by P. vulgatus to tridecylic acid production and Rho/CDC42-associated tight-junction signalling.

Design quality. Strengths include intervention fractionation, structural characterization, random allocation, blinded histology, germ-free transfer experiments and bacterial gene knockouts. Public Chinese research grants funded the work; the authors declared no conflicts.

Limits and bias. This remains a set of small animal and cell experiments using an acute chemical colitis model. No preregistration or power calculation is reported. The human datasets are observational and did not measure the proposed metabolite or host signalling. The Rho/CDC42 step was not tested with pathway blockade, and the Caco-2 methods section appears to label the fatty-acid exposure as myristic acid rather than tridecylic acid — a reporting inconsistency worth clarification.

Interpretation. This is a reasonably strong mechanistic advance for one purified fraction. It is not independent clinical replication and cannot be generalized to whole fruiting body, mycelium, crude extracts, other Ganoderma species or retail products.

Manuscript verdict

Add a watch note. Record GAP2 as fraction-specific mechanistic evidence; do not change any clinical grade. Monitor for independent replication and a human intervention using the same characterized fraction.

Source: Zhang C et al. Adv Sci (Weinh). 2026;e78105. Full text

Preclinical screen — not promoted: G. lucidum polysaccharide in isoproterenol cardiac injury

Peer-reviewed original paper | Journal of Natural Medicines | Published 5 October 2026.

Reported intervention. A material called Ganoderma lucidum polysaccharide (GLP), given to randomized mice orally at 50 or 100 mg/kg/day or intraperitoneally at 50 mg/kg/day. The comparator injury model received isoproterenol 2 mg/kg/day subcutaneously for 11 days. AC16 human cardiomyocytes were pretreated with GLP before 40 micromol/L isoproterenol for 24 hours.

Why it was not promoted. The accessible report does not provide the fungal strain, source tissue, extraction process, formulation, degree of purification, main animal group size, sex or blinded outcome procedures. The abstract reports 0.25–1.00 micrograms/mL GLP in cells, while the supplementary figure reports 0.025–0.900 mg/mL — a large unit/range discrepancy. Outcomes (cardiac hypertrophy, histology, AST/LDH, energy metabolites and oxidative-stress markers) improved, but AMPK/PGC-1alpha/PPAR-alpha involvement is associative rather than established by perturbation.

Funding/conflicts. National Natural Science Foundation of China grants; authors declared no competing interests. Two companies were thanked for analytical-instrument access.

Manuscript verdict

No change. Keep out of claim-supporting text unless the intervention provenance and dose-unit discrepancy are resolved.

Source: Zhang XT et al. J Nat Med. 2026

Citation integrity

Integrity watch


Journal notices and source problems are treated as evidence in their own right, with their status stated precisely.

Replication / null / correction watch

Conditional null: GAP1/GAP2 did not materially improve DSS outcomes when administered directly to germ-free mice; benefit appeared only after microbiota/metabolite transfer. This narrows the claim to a microbiota-dependent effect.

No independent replication: neither retained paper reproduces an established human medicinal-fungi effect.

No relevant correction, retraction or expression of concern was identified in the screened publication window.

A late-indexed Drosophila classroom micropublication reported inconsistent/null locomotor effects for Trametes versicolor and Inonotus obliquus extracts, and a non-specific locomotor effect for Hericium erinaceus. Product and dose standardization were inadequate for manuscript use.

Manuscript verdict

No change. GLP cardiac paper; late-indexed Drosophila extract screen; all clinical evidence grades.

Source: Drosophila classroom micropublication, DOI 10.17912/micropub.biology.002349

Decisions

Manuscript action ledger


The practical actions arising from this surveillance window.

DecisionAction
Change nowNone.
Add caveat / watch noteGAP2 is a purified, microbiota-dependent fruiting-body fraction; note the direct-treatment null in germ-free mice.
MonitorIndependent replication and a human study using the same characterized GAP2 fraction.
No changeGLP cardiac paper; late-indexed Drosophila extract screen; all clinical evidence grades.

The week adds a plausible microbial mechanism, not a treatment claim. If the manuscript already insists on intervention-specific evidence, its central argument is strengthened — its clinical conclusions are not changed.

Evidence surveillance ·

Medicinal Fungi Evidence Update

A FoTv preprint watch note, purified cordycepin in mice and a missed Ganoderma retraction


“One late-identified human preprint deserves a watch note, but it does not establish efficacy. No new peer-reviewed human trial or qualifying systematic review appeared. One preclinical cordycepin paper adds a mechanistic layer to an already replicated mouse-model signal. A previously missed Ganoderma retraction requires immediate citation hygiene.”

What changed

One late-identified human preprint deserves a watch note, but it does not establish efficacy. No new peer-reviewed human trial or qualifying systematic review appeared. One preclinical cordycepin paper adds a mechanistic layer to an already replicated mouse-model signal. A previously missed Ganoderma retraction requires immediate citation hygiene.

Evidence surveillance

Human clinical evidence


Newly indexed human evidence is assessed against the exact formulation and study design, without transferring results to a mushroom species or product category.

FoTv for mild-to-moderate COVID-19 (late-identified preprint)

Tested intervention

FoTv: a 50:50 blend of independently solid-state-fermented Fomitopsis officinalis (agarikon) and Trametes versicolor (turkey tail) mycelium with their fermented organic brown-rice substrate, in 500 mg pullulan capsules — eight capsules three times daily for 14 days (12 g/day). The placebo was dried cooked organic brown rice. Strain identifiers and quantitative beta-glucan or metabolite standardisation were not reported.

A revised medRxiv preprint posted 19 September 2026 — not peer reviewed — reports a dual-site, randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled phase-I trial in non-hospitalised adults with recently diagnosed mild-to-moderate COVID-19. It predates the last brief and is included now as a correction to the surveillance record. The analysed groups were 26 FoTv and 24 placebo participants; the prespecified primary purpose was safety and feasibility, not definitive efficacy.

Adherence and completion were high, and no hospital, emergency-department or urgent-care visits occurred. Exploratory repeated-measures analyses favoured FoTv for self-reported symptom count and severity. However, nasal SARS-CoV-2 viral load did not differ significantly. Estimated GFR declined within the FoTv group, although between-group levels and transitions to abnormal values did not differ. High-sensitivity troponin-T increased within the FoTv group; its significance is uncertain and deserves follow-up rather than a reassuring reinterpretation.

Allocation concealment and masking were credible. Confidence is nevertheless low because the trial was small, designed for safety, conducted during changing variants and vaccination uptake, and tested many exploratory symptoms, biomarkers and subgroups. The manufacturer supplied and helped fund the study; company-affiliated authors assisted with mycology literature review and writing. The authors declared no competing interests. The findings belong only to this 12 g/day myceliated-rice combination — not to either fungus generally.

Manuscript verdict

Add a watch note only. Record acceptable short-term feasibility, exploratory symptom signals and the null viral-load result. Await peer review and a properly powered efficacy trial before changing any clinical grade.

Source: Saxe et al., medRxiv preprint; trial NCT04667247

Narrative review: medicinal mushrooms and type 2 diabetes

No qualifying new systematic review or meta-analysis was identified. A peer-reviewed narrative review on medicinal mushrooms and type 2 diabetes was newly indexed. It is not a systematic review and supplies no new pooled estimate.

Its useful contribution is methodological: it highlights preparation heterogeneity, uncertain dose-response and pharmacokinetics, short trials, incomplete safety evaluation, possible mushroom–drug interactions, liver safety and contaminant screening. Those cautions reinforce the Atlas's existing chain-of-custody framework rather than changing an efficacy conclusion.

Manuscript verdict

No evidence-grade change. Consider the review as a supporting citation in the standardisation and safety-caveats sections.

Source: Medicinal mushrooms and type 2 diabetes: mechanistic insights, translational evidence, and clinical caveats

Laboratory and animal research

Preclinical signals


Signals that may justify monitoring or further investigation, but do not establish a human clinical effect.

Purified cordycepin in LPS-induced acute lung injury

Commercial cordycepin of 98% HPLC purity — a purified molecule, not a Cordyceps militaris powder or extract; its manufacturing or fungal source was not specified. Fifty male BALB/c mice were randomized to control, intranasal LPS 3 mg/kg, or LPS followed 24 hours later by oral cordycepin at 20, 40 or 80 mg/kg for three days (n=10/group). There was no established-drug positive control. Parallel MH-S macrophage experiments used 0.1, 1 or 10 micromolar cordycepin after LPS, plus TAK1 knockdown and overexpression.

Cordycepin reduced histological lung injury and several inflammatory measures, generally with stronger effects at higher doses. The cellular perturbation experiments support dependence on TAK1-related signalling. Molecular docking alone does not demonstrate direct physical binding. This is a partial replication of earlier reports that cordycepin reduces LPS lung injury, while adding a proposed TAK1/MAPK/NF-kappaB mechanism.

Strengths include randomized allocation, three doses, n=10/group and genetic pathway perturbation. Limits include no formal prospective power calculation, no stated blinded outcome assessment, males only, a short artificial LPS model, fixed treatment order without cage rotation, and no positive comparator. Public Chinese grants funded the work; no conflicts were declared. The peer-reviewed study was newly indexed 26 September 2026.

Manuscript verdict

Monitor only. If mentioned, describe this as purified cordycepin in an acute mouse model; do not transfer the finding to Cordyceps products or human respiratory disease.

Source: Peer-reviewed study, newly indexed 26 September 2026

Quality-filter exclusion: erinacine C

A peer-reviewed study administered purified erinacine C at 100 mg/kg/day by gavage for 16 weeks to female APP/PS1 mice. The treatment group contained five mice, with four transgenic vehicle controls and four wild-type controls.

Behavioural and pathology signals were positive, but the extremely small groups, single dose, absent positive comparator and unreported blinding keep it below the high-quality tier. This is evidence about erinacine C, not lion's mane powder, fruiting bodies or mycelial supplements.

Manuscript verdict

No change. Do not use this study to strengthen a human cognition or Alzheimer's claim.

Source: Erinacine C in APP/PS1 mice and PC12 cells

Citation integrity

Integrity watch


Journal notices and source problems are treated as evidence in their own right, with their status stated precisely.

Retraction audit correction — act now

The 2017 paper Restoration of the tumor-suppressor function to mutant p53 by Ganoderma lucidum polysaccharides in colorectal cancer cells has been retracted. The editor cited p53 western-blot bands previously used under different experimental conditions and suspicious similarities between flow-cytometry plots, concluding that confidence in the data had been lost. The authors accepted the retraction. The notice appeared in August but was missed in the previous surveillance pass; that omission is corrected here.

A separate correction to the 2026 C. militaris diabetic-wound mouse study added an omitted institutional affiliation for one author. No data, methods, figures or conclusions changed — citation maintenance only; no evidence change.

Manuscript verdict

Change now. Remove the retracted Ganoderma/p53 paper wherever cited. If a mechanistic statement rests substantially on it, delete or downgrade that statement until supported independently. The Cordyceps wound-healing correction changes an affiliation only.

Source: Retraction notice, Oncology Reports

Decisions

Manuscript action ledger


The practical actions arising from this surveillance window.

DecisionAction
Change nowRemove the retracted 2017 Ganoderma/p53 colorectal-cancer paper and reassess any dependent sentence.
Watch noteAdd the FoTv phase-I preprint: short-term feasibility, exploratory symptom signal, null viral load, safety uncertainties and manufacturer support.
MonitorPurified cordycepin in LPS lung injury pending independent, blinded and clinically relevant replication.
No changeClinical evidence grades; lion's mane cognition/Alzheimer's claims; species-wide Cordyceps or turkey-tail claims.
MaintenanceCordyceps wound-healing correction changes an affiliation only.

This week changes the manuscript chiefly through subtraction: one unreliable Ganoderma mechanism should leave the page. The new human signal remains a preprint watch item, not medicine.

Evidence surveillance ·

Medicinal Fungi Evidence Brief

A null maitake endpoint, Huaier pooled estimates and two preclinical signals


“One new human maitake trial merits manuscript attention, principally because its overall infection endpoint was null.”

What changed

One new human maitake trial merits manuscript attention, principally because its overall infection endpoint was null. A Huaier meta-analysis reports favourable cancer outcomes but does not resolve longstanding trial-quality and intervention-heterogeneity concerns. Two animal studies remain hypothesis-generating.

Evidence surveillance

Human clinical evidence


Newly indexed human evidence is assessed against the exact formulation and study design, without transferring results to a mushroom species or product category.

Maitake bread and upper-respiratory symptoms

Tested intervention

Bread providing the equivalent of 50 g fresh Grifola frondosa daily, prepared separately from strain Y10M or strain C5304; matched placebo bread. This was not a purified polysaccharide or solvent extract.

In this peer-reviewed, randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study, healthy adults aged 18–20 or 40–85 consumed the bread for 11 or 18 weeks, respectively. Approximately 165 participants were analysed across three groups.

The clinically important result was null: neither strain reduced the overall incidence of upper-respiratory-tract infection episodes. Secondary analyses associated Y10M—but not consistently C5304—with fewer days of fever and runny nose in both age cohorts, and fewer sore-throat days among younger participants. Y10M also altered several immune-cell and interferon-related measurements in older participants.

The design was comparatively strong, but confidence is limited by numerous symptom, subgroup and biomarker comparisons; self-reported illness; differing follow-up periods; and lack of virological confirmation. Moreover, the trial registry named complete blood count as its primary outcome, whereas the paper foregrounds respiratory symptoms and immunity. That mismatch raises outcome-selection concerns. The manufacturer funded the study and company-affiliated researchers were among the authors.

This is not evidence that “maitake prevents colds.” At most, it is a strain-specific secondary signal following a null overall infection result. The peer-reviewed study was published 21 September 2026.

Manuscript verdict

Change now. Add one restrained sentence recording the null primary clinical result, the exploratory Y10M symptom signals, C5304’s limited effects and the need for independent replication. Do not upgrade maitake’s clinical evidence grade.

Source: Peer-reviewed study and trial registration

Huaier added to conventional treatment for hepatocellular carcinoma

Tested intervention

Huaier—Trametes robiniophila Murr., also called Vanderbylia robiniophila—added to conventional antitumour treatment, compared with conventional treatment alone.

A peer-reviewed multi-method paper pooled 27 studies involving 2,880 patients. Pooled estimates favoured combination treatment for objective response (RR 1.40), disease control (RR 1.15), six-month survival (RR 1.20), one-year survival (RR 1.33) and recurrence (RR 0.74).

The accessible report does not establish a uniform Huaier preparation, dose or conventional-treatment regimen across studies. Nor does it provide enough detail to resolve concerns about allocation methods, blinding, publication bias and the reliability of numerous small Chinese oncology trials.

The accompanying network-pharmacology, docking and Jurkat-cell experiments propose IL-2/PI3K–Akt signalling. These analyses are mechanistic hypotheses, not confirmation that this pathway mediates clinical outcomes. The cell experiment lacked protein-level or in-vivo validation.

This review largely re-pools existing evidence rather than independently replicating it. Its favourable numbers should not be transferred to Huaier generally, other fungal products or monotherapy. The peer-reviewed study was published 19 September 2026.

Manuscript verdict

Add a caveat/watch note. Update the citation and pooled estimates if Huaier is discussed, while retaining the current uncertainty grade and specifying “Huaier plus conventional therapy.”

Source: Peer-reviewed multi-method paper

Laboratory and animal research

Preclinical signals


Signals that may justify monitoring or further investigation, but do not establish a human clinical effect.

Ganoderma lucidum polysaccharides with low-dose gemcitabine

In a mouse 4T1 breast-tumour model, a preparation described as G. lucidum polysaccharides was tested alone and alongside low-dose gemcitabine. The polysaccharides alone altered immune measurements but did not significantly suppress tumour growth. Gemcitabine reduced tumour volume, while the combination produced greater inhibition and was associated with CD8-cell infiltration, inflammatory cytokines, microbiome changes and altered tryptophan metabolism.

Fungal strain, tissue, extraction method, molecular-weight specification, dose, route and group size are not adequately reported in the accessible indexed record. The microbiome and metabolic observations are predominantly associative; kynurenine was not measured despite the proposed IDO mechanism. Public sequence and metabolomics deposits improve transparency. Public Chinese research programmes funded the study and the authors declared no conflicts. The peer-reviewed study was published 19 September 2026.

Manuscript verdict

Monitor pending replication. Preserve the null monotherapy result; do not describe Ganoderma generally as an anticancer treatment or gemcitabine sensitizer.

Source: Peer-reviewed study

Agrocybe chaxingu ethanol extract in ovariectomized rats

Cut fungal material was reflux-extracted for two hours in 95% ethanol. The resulting extract was administered orally at approximately 95, 190 or 380 mg/kg in an ovariectomized-rat osteoporosis model; alendronate at 1.4 mg/kg/day served as a positive control.

The extract improved bone-mineral density and several micro-CT, trabecular and serum measures. Microbiome and phosphate-transporter changes were proposed as mechanisms, but microbiome profiling appears to have been confined to the high-dose group. Without microbiota-transfer, depletion or pathway-blockade experiments, causality is unestablished.

Strengths include multiple doses, a relevant positive control and structural bone measurements. Limitations include the preventive animal model, incomplete strain and chemical standardisation, selective microbiome analysis and an author affiliation with Mushroom Wisdom, Inc. The peer-reviewed study was published 21 September 2026.

Manuscript verdict

Monitor pending replication. No clinical or general osteoporosis claim should change.

Source: Peer-reviewed study

Citation integrity

Integrity watch


Journal notices and source problems are treated as evidence in their own right, with their status stated precisely.

Replication, null and correction watch

Human null: Maitake did not reduce overall respiratory-infection incidence. Strain divergence: Y10M produced some secondary signals; C5304 generally did not.

Preclinical null: Ganoderma polysaccharides alone did not significantly inhibit 4T1 tumour growth.

No independent replication of a major medicinal-fungi clinical claim appeared. No relevant retraction, expression of concern or substantive correction was identified.

Manuscript verdict

Keep the null findings prominent and retain the existing clinical grades.

Source: Evidence surveillance search

Decisions

Manuscript action ledger


The practical actions arising from this surveillance window.

DecisionAction
Change nowAdd the strain-specific maitake RCT, leading with the null infection endpoint.
Add caveat/watch noteUpdate Huaier pooled estimates without upgrading certainty.
MonitorGanoderma–gemcitabine combination; A. chaxingu ethanol extract.
Clinical gradesNo upgrades.
Broad mushroom claimsNo change.

No independent replication of a major medicinal-fungi clinical claim, relevant retraction, expression of concern or substantive correction was identified in this surveillance window.

Evidence surveillance ·

Medicinal Fungi Evidence Update

Human evidence, preclinical signals and citation integrity


“This week's strongest evidence was not a new cure but a warning label — and sometimes that is exactly what rigorous surveillance is meant to find.”

What changed

One sizeable human observational study was newly indexed, but it tested a multi-ingredient vaginal gel — not Coriolus versicolor alone. No new randomised trial or systematic review qualified. The most important integrity finding is an Expression of Concern attached to a 2018 Ganoderma prostate-cancer paper.

Evidence surveillance

Human clinical evidence


Newly indexed human evidence is assessed against the exact formulation and study design, without transferring results to a mushroom species or product category.

Multi-ingredient Coriolus-based gel for low-grade cervical lesions

Tested intervention

Papilocare, a vaginal gel combining Coriolus versicolor with hyaluronic acid, Centella asiatica, Aloe vera, alpha-glucan oligosaccharide, Azadirachta indica and beta-glucan. The fungal strain, fungal material, extraction method and amount of Coriolus were not reported.

Participants used one application daily for 21 days, followed by alternate-day use for five months. Persistent cases could receive another six-month cycle. The prospective, open-label, non-comparative study enrolled 524 adults at 45 Greek sites; 494 completed follow-up.

Lesion regression was reported in 72.1% at six months and 75.9% overall. HPV clearance was reported in 72.0% of the 236 participants with suitable paired testing. Only 22 participants had paired baseline and 12-month biopsies. Two non-serious, possibly product-related adverse events were reported.

The large cohort and high retention are useful, but the absence of an untreated or placebo group is decisive: low-grade lesions and HPV can resolve spontaneously. HPV assays varied between sites and histological follow-up was sparse. The study therefore records outcomes during use; it cannot determine how much the gel caused them.

Evidence belongs to the complete formulation — not turkey tail, PSK, PSP, oral mushroom products or Coriolus generally. The work was funded by ELPEN Pharmaceutical; company employees were co-authors and several investigators received fees or support.

Manuscript verdict

Add only a narrow watch note for this exact formulation if cervical HPV products are discussed. Do not alter the Coriolus/PSK evidence grade.

Source: Full peer-reviewed report and trial registration

Systematic reviews and meta-analyses

No qualifying systematic review or meta-analysis was identified. A newly indexed psychiatric narrative review mentioned Hericium erinaceus, but supplied no new quantitative synthesis or intervention-specific clinical conclusion.

Manuscript verdict

No change.

Source: Evidence surveillance search

Laboratory and animal research

Preclinical signals


Signals that may justify monitoring or further investigation, but do not establish a human clinical effect.

Ganoderma lucidum spore oil in high-fat-diet mice

Mice received G. lucidum spore oil at 800 mg/kg/day for 82 days. The study reported reductions in weight gain, fasting glucose, blood lipids and inflammatory markers, accompanied by microbiome, short-chain-fatty-acid and bile-acid changes. Fecal fermentation and HepG2 experiments explored possible microbiota-related mechanisms.

Only one dose was tested. Sample size, allocation, blinding, fungal strain, oil-production method and chemical standardisation were absent from the indexed abstract. Microbiome associations do not establish microbial causation, and this mouse dose cannot be translated directly into a human supplement claim. Funding came from Chinese public research programmes.

Manuscript verdict

Monitor pending full chain-of-custody assessment and independent replication; no clinical-grade change.

Source: DOI 10.1002/jsfa.71035

Molecular-weight fractions from Grifola frondosa

An authenticated maitake fruiting-body lot underwent repeated hot-water extraction, ethanol precipitation, ion-exchange purification and ultrafiltration. The nominally below-1-kDa PP-3 fraction had an apparent mass near 184 Da and 15.72% residual protein. It is more accurately described as an oligosaccharide-rich fraction than a conventional polysaccharide.

PP-3 gave the strongest tumour-cell and macrophage assay effects, but concentrations were high and the study lacked normal-cell controls, established anticancer comparators and endotoxin testing. For distribution work, chemically FITC/iodine-labelled material was given orally at 1 g/kg to ten rats; ten controls received saline. Calculated blood absorption peaked at 5.25% after two hours, with iodine signals mainly in liver and kidney.

ICP-MS detected iodine, not intact native PP-3, and labelling could alter distribution. The work demonstrates neither oral maitake absorption nor anticancer efficacy; it is instead a useful lesson in evidence ownership and chemically altered tracers.

Manuscript verdict

No substantive change. Retain as a possible future illustration of intervention identity and tracer limitations.

Source: Peer-reviewed full text

Citation integrity

Integrity watch


Journal notices and source problems are treated as evidence in their own right, with their status stated precisely.

Expression of Concern: 2018 Ganoderma prostate-cancer paper

The journal has formally flagged the 2018 paper Ganoderma lucidum polysaccharide inhibits prostate cancer cell migration via the protein arginine methyltransferase 6 signalling pathway.

The notice identifies overlapping material in control and 5 microgram/mL image panels that were meant to represent different conditions. It also questions whether the antibody reported as detecting p21 instead recognised a different cytoskeleton-related protein. The journal is awaiting the authors' response.

This is an Expression of Concern rather than a retraction, but the paper should not currently support a claim.

Manuscript verdict

Check the bibliography for original DOI 10.3892/mmr.2017.7904. If present, quarantine or remove it and reassess any dependent sentence.

Source: Journal Expression of Concern

Decisions

Manuscript action ledger


The practical actions arising from this surveillance window.

DecisionAction
Check nowAudit the 2018 Ganoderma prostate-cancer citation.
Narrow watch notePapilocare is a multi-ingredient vaginal gel; never attribute its outcomes to Coriolus alone.
MonitorThe Ganoderma spore-oil metabolic mouse study.
Future illustrationMaitake PP-3 fractionation and tracer limitations.
Clinical gradesNo change.

No new independent clinical replication, relevant human null trial, retraction or qualifying preprint was identified in this surveillance window.

Editorial note

Scope and limits

These bulletins are evidence-surveillance updates for readers of The Fungal Evidence Atlas. They are not medical advice. Findings are confined to the exact preparations and study conditions described; evidence for a preparation must not be silently transferred to a mushroom species, supplement category or commercial product.