Skip to content
The Spore PatchPublishing · Evidence · Conservation
← All Fungal Evidence Updates

Evidence surveillance ·

Medicinal Fungi Evidence Update

Human evidence, preclinical signals and citation integrity


“This week's strongest evidence was not a new cure but a warning label — and sometimes that is exactly what rigorous surveillance is meant to find.”

What changed

One sizeable human observational study was newly indexed, but it tested a multi-ingredient vaginal gel — not Coriolus versicolor alone. No new randomised trial or systematic review qualified. The most important integrity finding is an Expression of Concern attached to a 2018 Ganoderma prostate-cancer paper.

At a glance

Human evidence items
2
Preclinical signals
2
Integrity notes
1
Manuscript decisions
5

Tap a heading to open or close each section.

Human clinical evidence(2)

Newly indexed human evidence is assessed against the exact formulation and study design, without transferring results to a mushroom species or product category.

Multi-ingredient Coriolus-based gel for low-grade cervical lesions

Tested intervention

Papilocare, a vaginal gel combining Coriolus versicolor with hyaluronic acid, Centella asiatica, Aloe vera, alpha-glucan oligosaccharide, Azadirachta indica and beta-glucan. The fungal strain, fungal material, extraction method and amount of Coriolus were not reported.

Participants used one application daily for 21 days, followed by alternate-day use for five months. Persistent cases could receive another six-month cycle. The prospective, open-label, non-comparative study enrolled 524 adults at 45 Greek sites; 494 completed follow-up.

Lesion regression was reported in 72.1% at six months and 75.9% overall. HPV clearance was reported in 72.0% of the 236 participants with suitable paired testing. Only 22 participants had paired baseline and 12-month biopsies. Two non-serious, possibly product-related adverse events were reported.

The large cohort and high retention are useful, but the absence of an untreated or placebo group is decisive: low-grade lesions and HPV can resolve spontaneously. HPV assays varied between sites and histological follow-up was sparse. The study therefore records outcomes during use; it cannot determine how much the gel caused them.

Evidence belongs to the complete formulation — not turkey tail, PSK, PSP, oral mushroom products or Coriolus generally. The work was funded by ELPEN Pharmaceutical; company employees were co-authors and several investigators received fees or support.

Manuscript verdict

Add only a narrow watch note for this exact formulation if cervical HPV products are discussed. Do not alter the Coriolus/PSK evidence grade.

Source: Full peer-reviewed report and trial registration

Systematic reviews and meta-analyses

No qualifying systematic review or meta-analysis was identified. A newly indexed psychiatric narrative review mentioned Hericium erinaceus, but supplied no new quantitative synthesis or intervention-specific clinical conclusion.

Manuscript verdict

No change.

Source: Evidence surveillance search

Laboratory and animal signals(2)

Signals that may justify monitoring or further investigation, but do not establish a human clinical effect.

Ganoderma lucidum spore oil in high-fat-diet mice

Mice received G. lucidum spore oil at 800 mg/kg/day for 82 days. The study reported reductions in weight gain, fasting glucose, blood lipids and inflammatory markers, accompanied by microbiome, short-chain-fatty-acid and bile-acid changes. Fecal fermentation and HepG2 experiments explored possible microbiota-related mechanisms.

Only one dose was tested. Sample size, allocation, blinding, fungal strain, oil-production method and chemical standardisation were absent from the indexed abstract. Microbiome associations do not establish microbial causation, and this mouse dose cannot be translated directly into a human supplement claim. Funding came from Chinese public research programmes.

Manuscript verdict

Monitor pending full chain-of-custody assessment and independent replication; no clinical-grade change.

Source: DOI 10.1002/jsfa.71035

Molecular-weight fractions from Grifola frondosa

An authenticated maitake fruiting-body lot underwent repeated hot-water extraction, ethanol precipitation, ion-exchange purification and ultrafiltration. The nominally below-1-kDa PP-3 fraction had an apparent mass near 184 Da and 15.72% residual protein. It is more accurately described as an oligosaccharide-rich fraction than a conventional polysaccharide.

PP-3 gave the strongest tumour-cell and macrophage assay effects, but concentrations were high and the study lacked normal-cell controls, established anticancer comparators and endotoxin testing. For distribution work, chemically FITC/iodine-labelled material was given orally at 1 g/kg to ten rats; ten controls received saline. Calculated blood absorption peaked at 5.25% after two hours, with iodine signals mainly in liver and kidney.

ICP-MS detected iodine, not intact native PP-3, and labelling could alter distribution. The work demonstrates neither oral maitake absorption nor anticancer efficacy; it is instead a useful lesson in evidence ownership and chemically altered tracers.

Manuscript verdict

No substantive change. Retain as a possible future illustration of intervention identity and tracer limitations.

Source: Peer-reviewed full text

Integrity watch

Expression of Concern: 2018 Ganoderma prostate-cancer paper

The journal has formally flagged the 2018 paper Ganoderma lucidum polysaccharide inhibits prostate cancer cell migration via the protein arginine methyltransferase 6 signalling pathway.

The notice identifies overlapping material in control and 5 microgram/mL image panels that were meant to represent different conditions. It also questions whether the antibody reported as detecting p21 instead recognised a different cytoskeleton-related protein. The journal is awaiting the authors' response.

This is an Expression of Concern rather than a retraction, but the paper should not currently support a claim.

Manuscript verdict

Check the bibliography for original DOI 10.3892/mmr.2017.7904. If present, quarantine or remove it and reassess any dependent sentence.

Source: Journal Expression of Concern

Manuscript decisions(5)
DecisionAction
Check nowAudit the 2018 Ganoderma prostate-cancer citation.
Narrow watch notePapilocare is a multi-ingredient vaginal gel; never attribute its outcomes to Coriolus alone.
MonitorThe Ganoderma spore-oil metabolic mouse study.
Future illustrationMaitake PP-3 fractionation and tracer limitations.
Clinical gradesNo change.

No new independent clinical replication, relevant human null trial, retraction or qualifying preprint was identified in this surveillance window.

These bulletins are evidence-surveillance updates, not medical advice. Findings are confined to the exact preparations and study conditions described.